Skip to main content
Hitler Years Disaster

The Hitler Years: Disaster, 1940-1945, Frank McDonough

The Hitler Years: Disaster, 1940-1945 is the eagerly awaited second volume in Frank McDonough’s new and extensive history of the Third ReichLiterally meaning the third realm or empire. It is the English name used to describe Nazi Germany, from 1933 until 1945.. Immediately following on from The Hitler Years: Triumph, this new volume charts the final peak of Nazi Germany’s successes in 1940 and early 1941 – the diplomatic gains, the huge military advances across the continent and the numerous crushing defeats of the Allies, all of which increased the government’s popularity at home – before documenting its catastrophic fall into chaos and absolute military and political defeat in 1945.

A book of this sort, covering a period of – to a greater or lesser extent – ‘total’ war necessarily focuses heavily on military campaigns. McDonough makes no bones about this, carefully narrating and analysing each major battle and the turning points they represented. As the book makes clear, it is important to understand the central place that war held within Nazi Germany and Hitler’s ideologyA system of ideas and ideals.: lebensraumGerman for 'living space'. Territory that is believed, particularly by the Nazis, to be needed for a state to exist., the search for living space for the German volkA German word that literally translates as 'people', but that often has ethnic and nationalistic connotations., could only be achieved through conquest. But it is equally important to understand that this space was to be achieved through expansion eastwards, taking lands from the ‘racially inferior’ – and therefore ‘unworthy’ – Slavic nations. So more than simply a volume of military history, McDonough’s The Hitler Years: Disaster provides insight into the German nation, its politics, and its mindset. Studying the regime at war and the way it fought on the different fronts neatly illustrates the racial and ideological motivation, not just of Hitler, but of the people, generals and common soldiery, that drove military strategy. Hitler’s diplomatic ability, flexibility, even his mental and physical health, are mapped against success and failure during the war, while the atrocities committed by the regime are shown as a reaction to the particular circumstances created by it.

This concentration on war and genocideThe deliberate killing of a large group of people, especially those of a particular nation or ethnic group. runs the risk of making any book on the subject a heavy and depressing read. Yet there are flashes of literary genius from McDonough that, while perhaps not making the book ‘enjoyable’, do make it engaging. This is not to say that McDonough makes light of the Nazi regime – his abhorrence for Hitler’s ideology is clear – but his approach is nuanced, subtle, and mature. It is exceedingly difficult for a historian of the Third Reich to take a balanced, ‘objective’ approach to the subject matter – after all, Hitler was ‘evil’, and the Allies were fighting a ‘just’ war – but McDonough achieves this and, in doing so, unpacks each myth in turn in a thoroughly convincing, well-evidenced manner. Criticism in the main is implicit: McDonough’s use of documentary and photographic primary sources does much of the leg work, allowing readers to draw their own conclusions. McDonough’s choice of case studies, the aspects he explains in detail and those that he merely mentions, highlights the ironies and complexities of the period, encouraging readers to think for themselves and challenge any number of notions that, in the past eighty years, have become something akin to modern foundation mythsMyths of origin that explain and give a narrative about a nation's past.. Nor is McDonough’s approach reserved just for those living within the Third Reich: very few of the major players, Allied or AxisThe states allied to Germany, Italy and Japan before and during the Second World War. The term 'Axis' helps differentiate them from the Allied powers (which included Britain and America)., come out of the book with an unblemished record. The reader can’t help but compare Hitler’s concern for the Parthenon and Athenian architecture favourably against the deliberate Allied bombardment of the ancient Benedictine abbey at Monte Cassino, while details of the plight of civilians in Dresden, Hamburg, and a multitude of other German cities leave an acrid taste in the mouth. In this manner, McDonough takes on the huge weight of historiographyThe study of writing history, or of history that has already been written. – and the politics behind it – in a masterful way.

Given the scope of the book, it is hardly surprising that one – in fact possibly the only – complaint might be that some aspects are given more attention than others. More space could, perhaps, have been devoted to the German massacres of Italian prisoners of war in Greece for example, but it is nearly impossible to condense satisfactorily so many elements, each warranting libraries of books themselves, into a mere two volumes. Instead, what McDonough has done, and done well, is to select his narrativeA story; in the writing of history it usually describes an approach that favours story over analysis. strands – for the second volume, particularly the war against the Soviet UnionThe Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) or Soviet Union, was a Marxist-Leninist state covering much of eastern Europe, Russia and Asia between 1922 and 1991., the collaboration of those within and without Germany, and the escalation of the persecution of Jews and other ‘untermenschenA Nazi term for non-Aryan racially 'inferior' people, including Jews and eastern European peoples, among others.’ – to create a narrative that is coherent and convincing, while allowing the reader to pursue other aspects through a comprehensive bibliography and notes. Thus, McDonough is practising the craft of the historian at the highest level.

The Hitler Years: Disaster and its companion volume, The Hitler Years: Triumph, are not just informative on a nearly encyclopaedic level, they are well-researched, well-structured, and well-written. What’s more, they are relevant and challenging. Through questioning the myths that still exist, they encourage the reader to think in a new way, not just about the past, but about the present and the future. The Hitler years weren’t just an aberration caused by the fanaticism of one man, but were a set of ideas actively supported by many in the army, the judiciaryThe systems and people (such as judges) relating to the practice of law., big business, and society at large. And nor was ‘right’ always on the side of the Allies, who fought the war for a number of economic and political reasons, and who afterwards turned a blind eye to the many war criminals who were left to retreat into obscurity. These two thought-provoking volumes, given the information they contain and the arguments they make, are, therefore, more than worthy of a place in the Hitler canon. They will be used for years to come as the essential starting point for any study of the Third Reich.

Author Info

Debbie Kilroy

Having read history at the University of Birmingham as an undergraduate, where I won the Kenrick Prize, I worked as a trouble-shooter in the public sector until I took a career break in 2009. Thereafter, I was able to pursue my love of history and turn it into a career, founding Get History in 2014 with the aim of bringing accessible yet high quality history-telling and debate to a wide audience. Since then, I have completed a Masters in Historical Studies at the University of Oxford, from which I received a distinction and the Kellogg College Community Engagement and Impact Award. As well as continuing to write for and expand Get History, I am now a freelance writer and historian. I have worked with Histories of the Unexpected and Inside History, and my article for Parliaments, Estates and Representation won the ICHRPI Emile Lousse essay prize (2019).

Buy this book
The Hitler Years: Disaster, 1940-1945, Frank McDonough
The Hitler Years: Disaster, 1940-1945, Frank McDonough
9.8
out of 10

Factual Accuracy

10/10

Readability

10/10

Content

9/10

Analysis

10/10

Pros

  • +Convincingly argued and thought-provoking
  • +Excellent use of sources and case studies
  • +Strong narrative
  • +Balanced, subtle approach
  • +Challenges myths

Cons

  • -Difficult to fit everything into one (or two) books
Buy this book